1
0.
Bibliographic Reference 1.
Object:
The
object of a text is the portion of reality it intends to study,
explain, describe, etc. For example, an essay about the fall of the
Roman Empire would be studying the Roman Empire; therefore, the object
would be "the Roman Empire", or even "the fall of the
Empire".
2.
Topic:
The
topic is the answer to the question "what is this text
about?"
3.
Problem
3.1
Problematic Facts: These
are the specific facts the author identifies and asks questions about.
They are directly related to the Object. The problematic facts
are things that amazed the author, made him ask questions. In the
example used above, these could be "the Roman Empire ended for
some reason", "the reasons historians have given for the
fall of the Empire don't really explain why it fell...", or many
others. 3.2
Question(s) (Objective): These
are the questions that arouse from observing the problematic facts,
and the author intends to answer with his text, article, essay,
conference, etc. An example could be "how did the Roman Empire
fall", or "how did the barbaric invasions affect the economy
of Rome", etc. 3.3
State of the Art: This
is the portion of the text that presents what other people have said
about the same topic and problem. This would include the information
the author of our example fictional text gives us about what others
said about the fall of Rome. 3.4
Importance of the Problem: This
refers to the reasons the author gives to support the fact that it is
important in some way to answer those questions, study that problem or
topic, etc. There is some argumentation here; the author is arguing
that his work is important and interesting. This would include, in the
example, the propositions that argue that it is important to
understand the fall of Rome, or to explain it more fully, etc.
4.
Solution
4.1
Hypothesis:
This refers to the propositions in the text which the author
shows as answers to the Question(s). They are the main propositions the author
tries to prove and convince his readers of. 4.2
Rationale:
This refers to the propositions that are
presented by the author
as supporting his Hypothesis(ses). Propositions in the rationale form a
network of reasons that support the hypothesis(ses).
5.
Conclusions:
This
is the part of the text where the author gives his concluding remarks,
usually summarizing his rationale, and restating his hypothesis and
answers. It could also include new questions that were left open or
new topics for further research.
6.
Bibliographic References:
This
part includes the complete bibliographic references of the articles,
books, etc. that were used to complete the scheme and understand the
text; only those which are different from the text itself are included
here. There could be no articles referenced here.

1
Taken and adapted from the Esquema de Lectura by professors
Felipe Pardo and Julia Baquero in their book La Argumentación en el
Texto Jurírico. Un instrumento para su comprensión. Bogotá:
Ministerio Justicia y del Derecho. 1997 |